Western Digital Raptor 36.7GB Serial ATA 10000RPM

Review: Allan "Zardon" Campbell

 

My test system of choice is :

Athlon Barton @ 245x10 - 2450mhz @ 1.9 core volt
Thermalright SLK900 and Ystech 92mm fan
Abit AN7 Nforce 2 mobo @ 245fsb
OCZ 4200 ram @ 7-4-3-2.5 @ 2.8 volts
Western Digital Raptor 36.7 gig drive
Western Digital JB SE 80 gig drive
Globalwin Sapphire 19db 520w PSU

Windows XP professional SP1
HDtach
Sandra Professional

All testing was done with a fresh format of each drive to ensure no fragmentation and to eliminate any possible corruption of accurate benchmarking data.

 

 

SiSoftware Sandra (the System ANalyser, Diagnostic and Reporting Assistant) is an information & diagnostic utility. It provides most of the information (including undocumented) you need to know about your hardware, software and other devices whether hardware or software.

 

Western Digital JB SE 80 gig - Drive index 30506

 

The western digital 80 gig drive (above) puts in an excellent set of results obviously helped by the 8 meg cache

Western Digital Raptor 36.7 Gig - Drive index 38268

 

A sterling set of figures for the Raptor with a reported average access time of 5ms, very low and the reference figure quoted by Western digital, the 80 GIG IDE drive has a reported acces time of 7ms, a little better than reported figures.

 

 

We are seeing noticeable increases across the board, abeit with a surprisingly low figure for the raptor in the buffered write test. This is more than likely due to the way the drive is designed rather than a fault of any kind and as I will report later, real world tests certainly do not show the drive to be slower in any area of performance. Sequential write is substantial higher >10mb

Fragmentation:

It is important when testing drives to ensure that it is either defragmented or a fresh format, "why?" I hear you ask. Check out the differences in the image at the top of this page and the one below detailing the 80 gig drive before a format with a one month old OS install.

Heavily fragmented drive, a clear indication of how fragmentation kills performance.

 

 

Next: further testing

 

Click here to go to application and install page Click here to go to pcmark2004 page Click here to go to the results page Click here to go to the conclusion page

 
Click here to go to application and install page Click here to go to pcmark2004 page Click here to go to the results page Click here to go to the conclusion page