Conclusion:
As we have seen from the testing, the results show significant
drops in chassis and overall temperature. The voodoo laptop
saw the lowest gains (drops in temperature) due in fact
to the underside chassis design. This laptop has NO vents
under the chassis, so the Vantec coolers simply were firing
cool air upwards at the chassis, very little reached inside
directly via fan vents. That said, some gains were seen,
and as the Vantec fans on full are no louder than the
chassis fans, this would be a worthwhile minimal outlay
to improve chassis temperatures. Especially for sustained
gaming or rendering durations.
Comparing the Vantec Lapcool 2 with the "eastern"
aluminium unit, it is clear to see even with noticeably
lower grade fans and no variable control, the aluminium
design is helping the laptop chassis to cool, as this
is acting as a massive heatsink. Still overall, if the
Vantec is toggled via the rear control to full fan power
it cooled all machines better, with Vantec showing their
superior fan technology can pay dividends. Hopefully with
version 3, we will see Vantec moving to Aluminium design
which most assuredly will lower chassis temperatures by
a further 1-2c.
It has to be said, that a part of the improved airflow
and subsequent drops in temperature are due to the fact
the lapcool2 is lifting the machine from the work surface,
and even with the plate fans turned off, will be helping
the airflow around the machine.
With the two designs, Vantec cater for a wide market,
those wanting a nice portable self powering cooling plate
with no external connectors and those wanting a home "dock"
with 4 more high speed USB2 devices attached. It is a
nice touch that even the 4 port USB2 version can be used
(minus USB support) without the power supply just like
the vanilla version. With regards to portable usage and
my rough estimates, battery life was reduced by 5-8% when
this was turned on at full fan speed, this is understandably
noticeable but not much worse than adding a few PCMCIA
cards to your system.
Compatibility is high, with the lapcool2 being able to
handle a diverse size of chassis design, it even held
the bethemoth Alienware Area 51m 7700 chassis, and trust
me that machine is HUGE. The leg mechanisms are very sturdy
and didnt even buckle the slightest under the 6kg+ weight.
As a test of the vantecs power, I disabled all the Alienware
chassis fans and ran prime 95 on a loop to see how long
it would take for system shutdown. This took around 4
minutes. With the Vantec Lapcool2 switched on and at full
power the machine managed to maintain stability for 25
minutes. A massive increase and a good indication that
the Vantec Lapcool2 is going to substantially aid the
life cycle of your machine.
As you would expect this isnt a miracle product, its
not going to drop your laptop temperatures by 15c during
heavy gaming sessions or resolve poor manufacturing chassis
design, but if you have a hot chassis which you find uncomfortable
or if you want to sustain the life of your laptop and
keep it cooler in operation then the Vantec Lapcool is
wholeheartedly recommended.
Vantec Lapcool2 are available from many stores and are
at time of press very reasonably priced. Id like to thank
Paul Terry at bluesharksystems
on ebay for supplying the review products. £24.99
for the vanilla and £39.99 for the 4 port USB2 hub
model.
